Black Kassel - Snack like Royalty
Montchevre: Celebrating Goat Cheese as it Should Be
Lactose-Free Bries
keep customers thrilled and coming back for more
Investigation Yields One Company's False Claim on 100 Percent Parmesan : Arthur Schuman Discusses

Investigation Yields One Company's False Claim on "100 Percent Parmesan": Arthur Schuman Discusses

Tuesday, February 16th, 2016

As transparency and authenticity continue to be top priorities for consumers and suppliers, more and more cases of fraudulent labeling are appearing, dipping into the pockets of deli businesses that work hard to meet those needs.

Next month, Castle Cheese Inc. President Michelle Myrter is scheduled to plead guilty for committing such crimes, according to Bloomberg. The FDA discovered in late 2012 that the Pennsylvania-based cheese company was doctoring its parmesan despite labeling it as 100% real genuine cheese, filling it in with cut-rate substitutes and fillers, including wood pulp, and distributing it to some of the biggest grocery chains in the U.S.

Neal Schuman, CEO, Arthur SchumanNeal Schuman, CEO of Arthur Schuman, explained to Bloomberg that he estimates that 20 percent of U.S. production — worth $375 million in sales — is mislabeled.

“The tipping point was grated cheese, where less than 40 percent of the product was actually a cheese product,” Schuman said, according to the report. “Consumers are innocent, and they’re not getting what they bargained for. And that’s just wrong.”

Schuman, seller of 33 percent of the domestic market of the U.S.’s hard Italian cheeses, operates firmly on giving consumers the real deal in hard Italian cheeses, which has grown to be one of the more popular options in the U.S. and also the most likely to have fillers.

Now, Bloomberg reports that the U.S. government has added its weight to the battle on fraudulent labels, defending the authenticity of the market.

“The industry wants to be known for a wholesome, safe, honest product — it’s what’s kept the industry growing for 100 years,” John Umhoefer, Executive Director of the Wisconsin Cheese Makers Association, commented, saying that the FDA’s investigation may be the change that the business needs. “The wholesomeness of dairy products is a treasured part of our story.”

Myrter faces either a $100,000 fine or a year in prison for the charges that cost industry operators millions.

DeliMarket News will continue to report on the case as it develops further.

Arthur SchumanWisconsin Cheese Makers Association

Black Kassel - Snack like RoyaltyMontchevre: Celebrating Goat Cheese as it Should BeLactose-Free Brieskeep customers thrilled and coming back for more

Have a new product, press release or story idea?

Let us know

In This Story

As a fourth-generation business, it’s no surprise that Schuman Cheese is driven by traditional family ideals. We take pride in the products we offer to consumers and customers alike, and we remain...

Wisconsin Cheese Makers Association gives voice to Wisconsin dairy processors on national and state issues that impact our business.

What a Chicken Wants: Windows, Wing Space, Outdoor Living, and More

Perdue Farms goes beyond the status quo and leads the way to enhance animal welfare standards.
View Press Release

Quick Access to Organic Commodity Prices Made Possible by Mercaris Partnership with DTN

DTN’s ProphetX solution will offer organic commodities data with The Mercaris Report.
View Press Release

Vienna® Beef Celebration Marks 125 Years as Chicago’s Favorite Hot Dog

Iconic hot dog brand welcomes governor and community for a Chicago-Style party.
View Press Release

Moo've Over, Yogurt: Kansas State University Students Win First Place in Dairy Council's New Product Competition

A new creamy protein-rich dairy drink has Kansas State University success written all over it.
View Press Release

Inc. Magazine Unveils Its 37th Annual List of America’s Fastest-Growing Private Companies—the Inc. 5000

For the 8th Time, Hissho Appears on the Inc. 5000, Ranking No. 3893. With Three-Year Revenue Growth of 91.7 Percent
View Press Release

WCMA Adds Staff as Member Services Expand

The association has welcomed Sara Schmidt as its new Office and Member Service Coordinator, working to support WCMA’s expanded array of benefits to member organizations.
View Press Release

Now It's Official! Flow is a Business Doing Good

BeeInventive, the company behind the multiple award-winning “honey on tap” FlowHive, is now a Certified B CorporationⓇ.
View Press Release

Hissho Among 2018 Middle Market Leaders

Hissho has just been named #8 among the 2018 Middle Market Leaders honorees by Charlotte Business Journal.
View Press Release

Halton Group Acquires U.S. Indoor Air Equipment Manufacturer

The acquisition makes the company a part of Halton's Foodservice business that specializes in professional kitchen environments.
View Press Release