Odyssey feta cheese. Delicious & award-winning. Wisconsin-made!
Eiffel Tower - A creamy cow’s milk delight, featuring a chalky white rind and a cream-colored, buttery, soft interior that oozes when at the peak of ripeness and temperature
Red Clay Gourmet's Michele Sawyer Discusses Company History, Ethos, and Product Line

Red Clay Gourmet's Michele Sawyer Discusses Company History, Ethos, and Product Line

Wednesday, March 7th, 2018

When a fan-favorite at Lance and Michele Sawyer’s restaurant/bar proved too popular for one single location, Red Clay Gourmet (RCG) was born. In just seven short years, the company has grown from a menu offering at the couple’s local restaurant to a full line of retail-ready pimento cheeses—offering small-batch artisan craftsmanship and taste in an impressive package to a growing group of enthusiastic consumers.

Michele Sawyer, Co-Founder, Red Clay Gourmet

I recently had the opportunity to talk to Michele and learn more about Red Clay Gourmet’s history, its ethos, and its exceptional products.

Q: Tell me a little about Red Clay Gourmet: When was the company founded and by whom?

Michele Sawyer: Red Clay Gourmet was an idea that began to grow legs in the Spring of 2010. My husband, Lance, and I own a little restaurant/bar in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, and we've had pimento cheese on the menu there for years. Over time Lance continuously tweaked the recipe, trying to find the perfect balance of flavor and texture. Our customers increasingly called him to order a pound or two for a party, a tailgate, or their vacation to the beach. He realized that our pimento cheese was unlike anything you could buy in the grocery store...that maybe there was something special there. So, he started working on some new flavor profiles, and we pitched a tent at a small, five-vendor farmer's market up the street. We sold 8 oz deli containers of our Classic Sharp, Hickory Smoked, and Flame Roasted Jalapeno—with a rudimentary sticker slapped on the lid.

Red Clay Gourmet products

Meanwhile, we were working with a local marketing firm on creating our brand and our retail packaging. Over the next year we started using a new labeled container, created the Goat Cheese & Sun-Dried Tomato flavor, pitched a tent at some larger farmers' markets, sold our cheese into some local shops and some shops in other North Carolina cities, added a new baby to our family (our son Maddock, now six, in addition to our daughter, Ellye, now eight), ordered our first IML packaging for each flavor, and landed a deal with our local Whole Foods Market.

We officially incorporated in September 2011 and delivered our opening order to Whole Foods on December 21, 2011.

Q: What would you say is the mission of Red Clay Gourmet?

MS: Our mission is to create delicious, unique, uncluttered food that brings people together, and that you can feel good about eating. We still make all of our pimento cheese by hand because we haven't found machines that do the job as well. Red Clay Gourmet will never compromise on the quality of the finished product or on the integrity of our raw ingredients. We are constantly refining our process and working with the specialty food community to innovate and to educate. But we are also working to build a business for our community—providing fun and fulfilling jobs for our friends and neighbors.

Red Clay Gourmet products

We chose to build our own production facility rather than finding a co-packer. So, we borrowed a bunch of money from our bank and built out a production kitchen and a small office in a 2,400-square-foot commercial unit.

It was a huge gamble—and one of the best decisions we ever made. We have total control of the process and the recipe. We can alter our ingredient ratios depending on the moisture content of a new batch of cheese. We can produce only what we need to fill our orders, thus preserving as much shelf-life as possible in our all-natural cheese spreads. We can detect an issue before it becomes a recall. Over the last five years we've tripled that space, and we're still bursting at the seams, so we're working with a developer on a new 20,000-square-foot facility that will be ready later this year!

Q: What distinguishes Red Clay Gourmet from other products on the market?

MS: Red Clay Gourmet offers three main distinguishing factors—flavor, texture, and quality. We buy the highest-quality ingredients to get the best flavor and texture. All of our cheeses are growth-hormone free and perfectly aged for optimal sharpness and moisture content.

We are the only national brand to use a non-GMO, cage-free egg mayonnaise, made without artificial preservatives, and we only use enough to keep the pimento cheese spreadable. The mayo is a binder in our recipe—not a filler or a flavor component. The majority of people who "don't like" pimento cheese are not fans of the mayo-to-cheese ratio—those are the people that we win over every day!

Red Clay Gourmet products

We get our jalapeños in fresh, from North Carolina farms, and roast and process them by hand. Using a fresh roasted pepper imparts tremendous flavor that you cannot achieve using pickled jalapeños. It's a lot of work, but it's totally worth it!

And while mixing and packaging 35-pound batches of cheese by hand is exhausting and time-consuming, we are able to create the perfect texture and consistency—where the cheese shreds are still intact but the other ingredients are well-incorporated. Our pimento cheese is not pasty or mealy or chunky; it is just right.

Red Clay Gourmet currently offers five unique flavors of pimento cheese, including:

  • Classic Sharp Cheddar
  • Hickory Smoked Cheddar
  • Goat Cheese & Sun-Dried Tomato
  • Flame Roasted Jalapeño
  • South Meets East Sriracha

And Michele tells me the company is constantly looking for new flavor profiles and testing new recipes. And with a new package debuting this spring and a new product line later this year, the future is looking bright for Red Clay Gourmet.

For more dairy, deli, and bakery news, stay tuned to Deli Market News.

Red Clay Gourmet

Odyssey feta cheese. Delicious & award-winning. Wisconsin-made!Eiffel Tower - A creamy cow’s milk delight, featuring a chalky white rind and a cream-colored, buttery, soft interior that oozes when at the peak of ripeness and temperature

Have a new product, press release or story idea?

Let us know

In This Story

A North Carolina-based specialty food producer that makes 4 delicious flavors of pimento cheese with the highest quality, all-natural ingredients.

Cheese Industry Conference 2019 Seminars Focus on Export Trends, Market Strategies

Grow your business in markets abroad with the help of expert insights on trends and winning sales strategies from 2019 Cheese Industry Conference (CIC) presenters.
View Press Release

WCMA Supports Dairy Industry’s Future Leaders with Scholarships Worth $15,000

Each year, the association shows its support for the dairy industry’s next generation of leaders by announcing the names of this year's recipients.
View Press Release

Eggland’s Best and Life Time Challenge Families to “Plus It Up”

Eggland’s Best (EB), the #1 branded egg in the U.S., is teaming up with the Life Time 60daySM program to encourage families to “plus it up” when it comes to their overall nutrition and wellness.
View Press Release

WCMA Recognizes Contest Leaders with Awards

On Wednesday, March 6, the Wisconsin Cheese Makers Association, host of the 2019 U.S. Championship Cheese Contest, honored Steve Krause, John Jaeggi, and John Umhoefer for their work to support and grow the contest.
View Press Release

WCMA Announces Ideas Showcase Line-Up at 2019 Cheese Industry Conference

Register online at CheeseConference.org through April 8!
View Press Release